Newsletter   Secure Checkout   Shopping Cart (0 Items)  
Search:    Welcome Guest! Save up to 30-40% on most items with our awesome everyday discounts!

Responsa: Literary History of a Rabbinic Genre [Hardcover]

By Peter J. Haas (Author)
Our Price $ 41.97  
Retail Value $ 59.95  
You Save $ 17.99  (30%)  
Item Number 146891  
Buy New $41.97
Out Of Stock!
Currently Out Of Stock
Currently unavailable...

Sbl Symposium Series - Full Series Preview
Image Title Price Stock Qty Add To Cart
  Prophecy in Its Ancient Near Eastern Context: Mesopotamian, Biblical, and Arabian Perspectives (Symposium Series (Society of Biblical Literature))   $ 23.66   In Stock  
  What Is John? Readers and Readings in the Fourth Gospel, Vol. 1   $ 31.56   In Stock  

Item description for Responsa: Literary History of a Rabbinic Genre by Peter J. Haas...

Responsa: Literary History of a Rabbinic Genre by Peter J. Haas

Promise Angels is dedicated to bringing you great books at great prices. Whether you read for entertainment, to learn, or for literacy - you will find what you want at!

Item Specifications...

Language: English
Studio: Scholars Pr
Pages   485
Est. Packaging Dimensions:   Length: 8.94" Width: 5.44" Height: 0.98"
Weight:   1.2 lbs.
Binding  Hardcover
Release Date   Jan 1, 1996
Publisher   Scholars Press
ISBN  0788502441  
ISBN13  9780788502446  

Availability  0 units.

More About Peter J. Haas

Register your artisan biography and upload your photo! Haas of East Carolina University

Peter J. Haas currently resides in the state of California. Peter J. Haas has an academic affiliation as follows - San Jose State University, USA.

Are You The Artisan or Author behind this product?
Improve our customers experience by registering for an Artisan Biography Center Homepage.

Product Categories

2Books > Subjects > Religion & Spirituality > Judaism > General
3Books > Subjects > Religion & Spirituality > Judaism > Sacred Writings > General
4Books > Subjects > Religion & Spirituality > Judaism > Sacred Writings

Reviews - What do customers think about Responsa: Literary History of a Rabbinic Genre?

shockingly bungled attempt at a scholarly book  Jul 14, 2001
This book claims to be a basic history of rabbinic responsa. But if you are really looking for a good book on that subject, you must look elsewhere, regrettably. Although the book was published by a well-known scholarly press, it would appear that the publisher did not ask anyone competent in rabbinics or talmudic jurisprudence to look over the book beforehand. It would also appear that the author himself rarely consulted standard translations of the Talmud, or even bothered to look up critically important words and phrases in commonly available talmudic dictionaries, such as Jastrow's.

As a result, the book is rife with mistranslations and misunderstandings of key Hebrew and Aramaic legal terms and concepts. For instance, Haas translates "arev kablan" as "one against whom a lien is held" although it really means "one who has guaranteed a loan." A more shocking example: Haas translates the legal term "din merumah" as "too much litigation," when in reality it means "court proceedings dealing with a fraudulent claim!" In both cases the correct translation of the mistranslated term could have been found in any Aramaic or Hebrew dictionary, or in any standard English edition of the Talmud. As a result of serious mistakes like these, most of the legal discussions and analyses found in this book end up being irrelevant to the subject and merely extended flights of fancy. To state it frankly, many of the longer translations of passages in rabbinic literature are no more than gibberish.

The most shocking example, in my opinion, of Haas building up major theses on mistaken premises can be found on pages 150-151: Regarding a certain responsum of Rashi he writes, "What the responsum does not do is the one thing we might expect, namely, to frame matters explicitly around talmudic precedents. . ." The surprising truth is that in reality this very responsum uses no fewer than SIX talmudic prooftexts! Haas's translation of the responsum shows that he simply did not recognize passages from the Talmud when they were being quoted or cited! (If he had, he might have looked them up and translated them correctly!) Basing himself on this erroneous assessment, Haas claims that Rashi was not interpreting the Talmud and applying its rulings on the authority of its authors, but was actually making up the law on his authority, as he felt right, and was utilizing talmudic jargon merely to obfuscate the matter for the laity! He writes, "The nature of the discourse is such as to discourage secular adjudication by invoking technical, one might say, holy discourse of the rabbinate."

Although Peter Haas holds a Masters degree from Hebrew Union College, is an ordained Reform rabbi, and holds a Ph.D. in Jewish Studies from Brown University (supervised by, not surprisingly, none other than that infamous academic charlatan, Jacob Neusner) he does not seem to possess any competence in or even basic familiarity with talmudic and rabbinic jurisprudence. It is profoundly disconcerting that such a book could be authored by an Ivy-League-trained scholar and published by a scholarly press. For a thorough critical (and sometimes humorous) review of this sad book, read Dr. Haym Soloveitchik's essay in volume 24 issue 1 (1999) of the prestigious AJS Review. (AJS=Association for Jewish Studies)


Write your own review about Responsa: Literary History of a Rabbinic Genre

Ask A Question or Provide Feedback regarding Responsa: Literary History of a Rabbinic Genre

Item Feedback and Product Questions
For immediate assistance call 888.395.0572 during the hours of 10am thru 8pm EST Monday thru Friday and a customer care representative will be happy to help you!

Help us continuously improve our service by reporting your feedback or questions below:

I have a question regarding this product
The information above is incorrect or conflicting
The page has misspellings or incorrect grammar
The page did not load correctly in my browser or created an error.

Email Address:
Anti Spam Question. To combat spammers we require that you answer a simple question.
What color is the sky?
Leave This Blank :
Do Not Change This Text :

Add This Product Widget To Your Website

Looking to add this information to your own website? Then use our Product Widget to allow you to display product information in a frame that is 120 pixels wide by 240 pixels high.

    Copy and paste the following HTML into your website and enjoy!

Order toll-free weekdays 10am thru 10pm EST by phone: 1-888-395-0572 (Lines are closed on holidays & weekends.)
Customer Service | My Account | Track My Orders | Return Policy | Request Free Catalog | Email Newsletter

Gift Certificates
RSS Feeds
About Us
Contact Us
Terms Of Use
Privacy Policy