Item description for Learn Spanish With Superman 1: Up, Up, and Away! (Learn Spanish With...) by Mark Millar...
Overview Presents a series of adventures of Superman, with simple dialogue containing Spanish words and phrases, with short notes and translations on the margins.
Promise Angels is dedicated to bringing you great books at great prices. Whether you read for entertainment, to learn, or for literacy - you will find what you want at promiseangels.com!
Studio: Berlitz Guides
Est. Packaging Dimensions: Length: 9.8" Width: 6.8" Height: 0.3" Weight: 0.3 lbs.
Release Date Dec 15, 2007
Publisher Berlitz Guides
ISBN 9812681795 ISBN13 9789812681799 UPC 027793681797
Availability 0 units.
More About Mark Millar
Mark Miller is a cult media superstar whose work has been turned into major Hollywood movies while his writing regularly garners mainstream media attention. He is known for his comic book writing on titles such as his award-winning run on "The Authority", as well as "The Ultimates", "Marvel Knights Spider-Man", "Ultimate Fantastic Four" and "Civil War". His titles, "Wanted" and "Kick-Ass", have both been adapted into major feature films.
Reviews - What do customers think about Learn Spanish With Superman 1: Up, Up, and Away! (Learn Spanish With...)?
You don't even have to buy it to know it's junk. Jan 8, 2009
I was at the local bookstore looking for something to read in Spanish. I find novels and short stories to be tiring to read in Spanish because my level isn't all that good, but comics are considerably easier... but the only comic book I'd seen on the shelves was Condorito: La Aventura Comienza, which I already have (and is only amusing because the jokes are so bad). Then I saw one of these books and I thought, hey! Superman in Spanish! That'd be perfect! I'm not a big fan of superheroes, but I didn't care: ANY decent comic in Spanish would be great.
Then I actually opened it and my hopes were dashed: the comic was not written in Spanish. No, it was written in English, with Spanish phrases randomly thrown in! Worse, they were all easy phrases I already knew, so I wouldn't learn anything at all! (You can use this site's "Look Inside!" feature and see for yourself.)
This comic is only a gimmick. It might prove entertaining for somebody who is just starting to learn Spanish, but it's really not a good way to either study or review what you've learned. After all, if you want to learn Spanish, you should be reading Spanish, not Spanglish. English and Spanish don't even fit together all that well... sometimes the same sentence will be structured completely differently between the two languages. One of the big obstacles a Spanish student will have is overcoming thinking in English. Books like these do nothing to help the student understand how Spanish differs from English and might even further the misconception in the student's mind that Spanish is just English with a different vocabulary.
I just can't comprehend why they didn't just print the entire thing in Spanish in the first place. They have plenty of margin space to provide definitions, most of which is unused because they didn't use nearly enough Spanish to fill in the margins -- even though every single Spanish phrase has a definition in the margin! Even definitions like "Computadoras: computers". Gee, thanks. I never could have figured that one out.
I have a hard time believing that anybody but the most casual learner of Spanish could get any value out of this, and I think even they have better choices. Nevertheless, I decided to give it two stars instead of one, because I suppose it's very good for what it is. It's just that what it is isn't very good.