Reviews - What do customers think about Crescent Moon Rising?
Disturbing reading Mar 12, 2006
I have to say first that I was given this book for Christmas and I had not heard of it before. My initial reaction to the cover was suspicion that this was a cheap sensationalist effort and the picture of the author did not reassure me (apologies to the author). Having stated my prejudices, I have to say that I found myself turning the pages rapidly. It is an easy and enticing read, constructed as it is, of short segments dealing with characters, events and relationships that reappear through the book. By the final chapters, much of my initial suspicion was replaced with an awareness that this was written by someone who has a lot of personal inside information. That much of what is presented is plausible and disturbing. For the importance of this insight into a history of events which are shaping our world I have given the book its 4 stars. That is not to say that I necessarily think the book is great literature. I don't for example think that the blend of factual journalism and fictional narative are blended convincingly. Also one is constantly wondering where the facts end and the fiction begins which tends to undermine the credibility somewhat. Having said all that, I believe the most important aspect of this book is that it makes you think! And certainly a few beaurocrats and politicians should be losing some sleep over it!
Essential reading ( Washington Defense and Foreign Affairs) Dec 1, 2005
New Study Maps Complex Web of Nationalist, Islamist Links and History of Indonesian, SE Asian Terrorism
Analysis. Staff Report. A new book by veteran intelligence officer and author Kerry Collison1 has emerged as essential reading for any analyst or official attempting to make comprehensible the complex, and often contradictory, web of historical factors and relationships which led to the two sets of terrorist bombings in Bali, Indonesia, in 2002 and 2005, and the array of terrorist and nationalist unconventional warfare undertakings in Indonesia and across South-East Asia over the past few decades. The study makes clear that Jamaah Islamiyah (JI) and its related organizations, such as Laskar Jihad (LJ) and Abu Sayyaf, are far from finished in their mission, or their relationship with the global al-Qaida movement, and remain sustained by many aspects of the nationalist and economic societies they seek to destroy.
The book, Crescent Moon Rising,2 was, like a number of Collison's books, written as a "fact-based political thriller" to enable the author to get around Indonesia's delicate libel laws as well as to place all the historical facts into a narrative matrix which allows the broad sweep of cultures, historical developments, and characters within a framework where the events, and people, start to make sense.
For the professional intelligence reader, the fictional narrative used to bind the historical data into a context does not get in the way of Collison's case presentation, but makes it easy reading and a way to get analysts - even those only marginally familiar with Indonesian history and politics - into a frame of reference which makes the topic intelligible. Collison has decades of experience in Indonesia, and knows virtually all of the key players on all sides of the Indonesian military and intelligence spectrum, for example. This earlier had made him perhaps the first commentator to highlight the fact that current Indonesian Pres. Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono would rise to the national leadership.
Among the things which Collison highlights are:
1. The firm and clear linkage between the Indonesian Islamist movements and the al-Qaida movement of Osama bin Laden and the less-than-formal, and always fluid, way in which targeting, inter-group cooperation, and financing are achieved;
2. The linkage between the terrorist groups and some key elements of the Indonesian National Military Forces (TNI: Tentara Nasional Indonesia) in the constant battle for power between the "Red and White" (nationalist) and "Green" (Islamist) elements of the TNI;
3. The rôle of South-East Asian-based front
companies in financing and logistical support for terrorist and insurgent groups across the region, linking Islamist activities in Indonesia, Thailand, the Philippines, Singapore, and Australia;
4. The breakdowns in trust and intelligence exchanges between the US, Australia, and other players - often apparently for reasons of compartmentalization and national objectives - which enabled some terrorist operations to proceed unhindered, including the Bali 1 bombings (2002), some of the Jakarta bombings, and the September 11, 2001, attacks on the US;
5. The impact of the South-East Asian economic collapse on terrorist activities;
6. The rôle of the Dutch Government and secessionist
elements (or elements which never supported the creation of Indonesia in the first place) within Indonesia in attempting to seek independence for the Moluccas and West Papua, and the potential rôles of
the People's Republic of China (PRC) and others in possibly pushing for United Nations plebiscites on the independence of those territories;
7. The resultant psychological attitudes within the TNI and Islamist movements toward Australia from Australia's late, and reluctant, rôle in assisting the
independence of East Timor;
8. The linkages between Laskar Jihad's activities and the "red and white" and "green" TNI factions' objectives in seeking to retain Indonesian national unity through creating, artificially, the tensions between Christian and Muslim communities in the Moluccas, Ambon, etc., leading to major rampant killing operations by Laskar Jihad and related movements, such as Komando Jihad (leading to the rise, and reinforcement of such Christian movements as the Coker boys, as well as to the Moluccan independence movement);
9. Background details on the key terrorist players in the situation, including such figures as Hambali, Syafullah al-Yemeni, Omar al-Faruq, Omar Ibn al-Khattab, Ramzi Yousef, Khalid Shaikh Mohammed, Abu Sapara, and so on, and some of the intelligence players on the US and Australian side of the equation; and
10. An understanding of relevant US, Indonesian, and Australian intelligence agency functions as they relate to the situation.
Collison does not neglect the linkages of the groups into Afghanistan and Chechnya, noting, quite apart from the concerns over the acquisition by Islamist-jihadist groups related to Osama bin Laden of "suitcase" nuclear weapons, the prospect and probability that the South-East Asian operations have acquired former Soviet Radio Thermal Generators (RTGs), which could be employed as substantial-scale "dirty" bombs.
Given the current overall climate of the US-led "war on terror", and the consequent need to create a viable and unified Indonesia (as far as the US and Australia are concerned), and the longer-term Chinese strategic desire to see a break-up of a Western-oriented Indonesia controlling both strategic resources and strategic waterways critical to Chinese interests, Collison's book is essential reading for analysts and policy officials attempting to understand the situation. Moreover, the book brings into perspective the factors which lead to state sponsorship of, or acquiescence to, many aspects of terrorism.
1. Kerry Collison, a former Australian military intelligence officer, is Indonesian correspondent for Defense & Foreign Affairs/Global Information System (GIS). He is the author of numerous books on Indonesia and South-East Asia.