Newsletter   Secure Checkout   View Cart (0 items)  
Search:    Welcome Guest! Save up to 30-40% on most items with our awesome everyday discounts!

Realism in the Sciences: Proceedings of the Ernan McMullin Symposium, 1995 (Louvain Philosophical Studies , No 10) [Paperback]

Our Price $ 36.75  
Retail Value $ 52.50  
You Save $ 15.75  (30%)  
Item Number 184755  
Buy New $36.75
Out Of Stock!
Currently Out Of Stock
Currently unavailable...

Item description for Realism in the Sciences: Proceedings of the Ernan McMullin Symposium, 1995 (Louvain Philosophical Studies , No 10) by Igor Douven...

Realism in the Sciences: Proceedings of the Ernan McMullin Symposium, 1995 (Louvain Philosophical Studies , No 10) by Igor Douven

Promise Angels is dedicated to bringing you great books at great prices. Whether you read for entertainment, to learn, or for literacy - you will find what you want at!

Item Specifications...

Studio: Cornell University Press
Pages   216
Est. Packaging Dimensions:   Length: 9.2" Width: 6.2" Height: 0.6"
Weight:   0.75 lbs.
Binding  Softcover
Publisher   Cornell University Press
ISBN  9061867630  
ISBN13  9789061867630  

Availability  0 units.

More About Igor Douven

Register your artisan biography and upload your photo! Igor Douven has an academic affiliation as follows - Rijksuniversiteit Groningen, The Netherlands Centre National de la Rec.

Are You The Artisan or Author behind this product?
Improve our customers experience by registering for an Artisan Biography Center Homepage.

Product Categories

1Books > Subjects > Nonfiction > Philosophy > General
2Books > Subjects > Science > General
3Books > Subjects > Science > History & Philosophy > Science
4Books > Subjects > Science > History & Philosophy

Reviews - What do customers think about Realism in the Sciences: Proceedings of the Ernan McMullin Symposium, 1995 (Louvain Philosophical Studies , No 10)?

Symposium or Seance?  Mar 15, 2006
This book includes the Reverend Ernan McMullin's latest rendering of realism given at his symposium at the Roman Catholic University of Louvain, Belgium, where he received his Ph.D. in philosophy in the 1950's. The Reverend McMullin was later University of Notre Dame's philosophy department chairman.

The Reverend's Ph.D. dissertation thesis is that quantum theory is interpreted by operationalist definitions. This means that quantum theory is not a literal description of microphysical reality - a thesis inconsistent with contemporary scientific realism. Ironically by denying realism to quantum theory the Reverend took basically the same instrumentalist view towards quantum theory that the Vatican had taken toward the Copernican theory when the pope condemned Galileo.

Later in "Case for Scientific Realism" in Scientific Realism (1984) the Reverend's thesis was that quantum theory is only metaphorical and not literally descriptive. He offered no theory of metaphor. And this view is not scientific realism. Furthermore he is wrong: theories are literal. As even van Fraassen notes, if a theory contains the statement "electrons exist", then it says that electrons exist!

In this book, Realism in the Sciences, the Reverend discusses "virtues" he finds operative in theory appraisal, a discussion in which he still retains positivist views of "observation", "law", "theory" and "explanation". The Reverend McMullin is evasive; he says that a detailed account of how these "virtues" argue for realism awaits some other occasion. Whatever that occasion, that account will not come: realism is not a logical conclusion to be argued; it is the primordial prejudice to be recognized and accepted. Most of this book is more positivist dithering about the semantical significance/ontology of theoretical terms.

Positivism is dead. In fact it's so dead that positivists don't want to be called "positivists", and they fabricate caricatures of it to distance themselves from it. But there is enough positivism in these articles including the Reverend's to call his symposium a necromancing seance with positivism's ghost. I did not observe that any of the philosophers contributing to this book received their graduate education in the U.S., so not surprisingly none of them reveal appreciation for contemporary American pragmatism.

Catholic philosophers love their absolutes whether delivered by Thomistic simple apprehensions or positivist operational definitions, but they recoil at the semantical and ontological relativism in contemporary pragmatism. I found in my personal experience that they are always the rear guard, protective of the past and paranoid of the future. Pragmatism has been the prevailing philosophy of science for the last thirty years, and still is. In my view therefore the Reverend and his brethren are philosophy's "left behind."

American Catholic colleges are typically small liberal arts schools lacking budgets for science, and thus have little or no interest or faculty slots in philosophy of science. Notre Dame's graduates must therefore often compete disadvantageously with tax-supported university graduates for available faculty appointments in philosophy of science in the tax-supported schools. But the Vatican will likely have no objections to the philosophical views in this book.

Google to my web site philsci, History of Twentieth-Century Philosophy of Science, for free downloads.

Thomas J. Hickey

Write your own review about Realism in the Sciences: Proceedings of the Ernan McMullin Symposium, 1995 (Louvain Philosophical Studies , No 10)

Ask A Question or Provide Feedback regarding Realism in the Sciences: Proceedings of the Ernan McMullin Symposium, 1995 (Louvain Philosophical Studies , No 10)

Item Feedback and Product Questions
For immediate assistance call 888.395.0572 during the hours of 10am thru 8pm EST Monday thru Friday and a customer care representative will be happy to help you!

Help us continuously improve our service by reporting your feedback or questions below:

I have a question regarding this product
The information above is incorrect or conflicting
The page has misspellings or incorrect grammar
The page did not load correctly in my browser or created an error.

Email Address:
Anti Spam Question. To combat spammers we require that you answer a simple question.
What color is the sky?
Leave This Blank :
Do Not Change This Text :

Add This Product Widget To Your Website

Looking to add this information to your own website? Then use our Product Widget to allow you to display product information in a frame that is 120 pixels wide by 240 pixels high.

    Copy and paste the following HTML into your website and enjoy!

Order toll-free weekdays 10am thru 10pm EST by phone: 1-888-395-0572 (Lines are closed on holidays & weekends.)
Customer Service | My Account | Track My Orders | Return Policy | Request Free Catalog | Email Newsletter

Gift Certificates
RSS Feeds
About Us
Contact Us
Terms Of Use
Privacy Policy